Plum Bun: A Novel Without a Moral - A Deep Dive Review

by Jessie Redmon Fauset (Author)

Updated at: 11/02/2025

Jessie Redmon Fauset's Plum Bun: A Novel Without a Moral is a captivating Harlem Renaissance novel exploring the complexities of identity and self-discovery. Angela Murray, a light-skinned African-American woman, makes the daring choice to "pass" as white, seeking freedom from racial constraints. Fauset masterfully portrays Angela's journey through a racially divided society, revealing the illusory nature of escaping prejudice. More than a romance, Plum Bun is a poignant coming-of-age story and a sharp social critique. It examines the interwoven forces of racism, sexism, and capitalism, forcing Angela – and the reader – to confront the true meaning of self-acceptance and fulfillment beyond the superficiality of race. This timeless novel remains remarkably relevant in its exploration of identity and the pursuit of belonging.

4.4 / 144 ratings

Review Plum Bun

I thoroughly enjoyed "Plum Bun: A Novel Without a Moral"! It arrived quickly and in perfect condition, which was a pleasant start. But the real pleasure was the book itself. Fauset's writing, while reflecting the style of the 1920s, was surprisingly accessible and engaging. I never felt lost or overwhelmed by the language, even though it's a period piece. The story itself is a captivating blend of romance, social commentary, and a coming-of-age narrative that feels remarkably relevant even today.

Angela Murray's journey is complex and, at times, frustrating. I found myself both empathizing with her struggles and occasionally exasperated by her choices. The novel doesn't shy away from portraying the difficult realities of racial prejudice and the limitations placed upon women in that era. Seeing Angela navigate the privileges and pitfalls of "passing" as white was both fascinating and unsettling. It highlighted the absurdity and cruelty of a society so rigidly defined by race. The author cleverly uses Angela's experiences to unpack not just the racial dynamics of the time but also the complexities of gender roles and the often-conflicting pressures of societal expectations versus personal desires.

While the central romance felt a bit contrived at times – a common criticism I've seen echoed elsewhere – it didn't detract significantly from my overall enjoyment. The book's strength lies in its exploration of identity and the search for self-acceptance in a world that actively tries to deny individuals their true selves. Angela's experiences resonate powerfully, forcing the reader to consider the choices she makes within the context of her environment. Did she make the right choices? That's a question the book leaves hanging, and that's precisely what makes it so thought-provoking.

The inclusion of Angela's mother's perspective offered a compelling counterpoint. Her approach to "passing" was more nuanced, suggesting a form of playful resistance rather than a complete rejection of her identity. This contrast illuminates the varying ways in which individuals within the same community respond to systemic oppression. The novel doesn't offer easy answers; it presents a realistic and multifaceted portrayal of life during the Harlem Renaissance, challenging readers to grapple with the ethical and emotional dilemmas faced by its characters.

In short, "Plum Bun" is a rich and rewarding read. It's a historical novel that remains surprisingly contemporary in its themes and its exploration of universal human experiences. While Angela's journey might occasionally test your patience, the overall narrative is compelling, the writing is elegant, and the social commentary is sharp and insightful. I highly recommend it.

See more: Book review of The Age of Innocence